First-Time Buyers Are 40: What This Means for Selling Your Home

The typical first-time homebuyer in America is now 40 years old. Let that sink in for a moment. We're talking about people who are closer to getting the senior discount at Denny’s than they are to their high school graduation when they buy their first home.

Buyer age across all categories has been increasing, with a new median age of 59. Where it was once driven by young families, the housing market is now dominated by older adults and repeat buyers, which means the rules of listing, staging and pricing have changed. Sellers who ignore this new reality risk leaving money on the table.

At Golden Homes Group MN, we’re walking you through how the market has evolved in recent years and what this means for you if you’re looking to sell your home. 

How We Got Here

The increase in first-time homebuyer age has been sudden and swift. When the NAR began tracking this data in 1981, the typical first-time homebuyer was just 29 years old. That number stayed relatively stable for decades, never ticking past 33. Then something changed. Between mid-2021 and mid-2022, it spiked to 36. By 2024, it hit 38, and now we're at 40.

For millennials and Gen Z, the increasing age of first-time homebuyers is not surprising. They’ve grappled with stagnant wages, inflation, student loan debt, high rent, high home prices, and an ever-rising cost of living for years. Most are just trying to get by, let alone save money for a down payment. 

Meanwhile, people who already own homes are accruing huge amounts of equity, thanks to soaring property values and low mortgage rates. This puts them in a position to make large down payments and all-cash offers. Moves that many first-time buyers can’t compete with. 

It all adds up. The most recent NAR report tells a similar story: among all buyers, only 21% are first-time buyers, a record low, while repeat buyers make up the vast majority of purchases. ​

What This Means for Sellers

Understanding the shift in demographics is essential information that should shape how you approach selling your home. 

You're Dealing with Older, More Established Buyers
The typical homebuyer today isn't a 28-year-old stretching their budget to afford their first place. The median age of all buyers climbed to 59, up from 56 the year before, with repeat buyers having a median age of 62. These buyers have more financial resources and completely different needs than the young families that traditionally drove the housing market.

Cash Is King More Than Ever
Between mid-2024 and mid-2025, 26% of all the homes sold went to all cash buyers. Yep, another record high. But what does this mean for you? Faster closings and fewer contingencies, as cash buyers are less likely to have deals fall through due to loan or appraisal issues.

The "Starter Home" Concept is Pretty Much Dead
Buyers aren't looking at their first home as a stepping stone anymore. They're waiting longer, saving more, and going straight for the house they actually want to live in long-term rather than buying something small with plans to move up in a few years. This brings down demand for starter homes and reduces churn in the market. Compounding the issue is that those who did buy a starter home during the pandemic (when mortgage rates were at their lowest) are holding onto them, so they never become available for the next wave of buyers. 

How Sellers Can Stand Out 

Once you understand who's actually shopping for homes today, you can tailor your approach to appeal directly to them. Smart positioning can mean the difference between a home that sits on the market and one that sells quickly at the right price.

Price Realistically for Your Market
​With older, more financially established buyers dominating the market, you might think you can push pricing higher. But remember, these buyers are also more experienced and less emotionally driven than first-time buyers. They know what homes are worth and aren't likely to overpay just because they're excited about homeownership. Especially repeat buyers. 

Make Sure Your Home Is Move-In Ready
Both older millennials who are buying their first home and repeat buyers want a home, not a project. In today’s market, most buyers prefer to avoid the stress and cost of renovations. Homes that are well-prepared, recently updated and low maintenance directly appeal to this group, so pre-listing improvements can go a long way.

Highlight Features That Appeal to Mature Buyers
Think about what someone in their 40s, 50s or 60s wants versus someone in their 20s or 30s:

• Single-floor living or master suites on the main level
• Low-maintenance landscaping and exterior materials
• Updated, accessible bathrooms (hello, wet room trend!)
• Energy efficiency and modern systems
• Quiet neighborhoods with established amenities
• Proximity to healthcare, shopping and cultural activities

Consider the Financing Reality
While many buyers are bringing more cash to the table, first-time buyers are still out there making median down payments of 10%, tapping financial assets like 401(k)s and investment accounts. One in five are depending on gifts or loans from family or friends. This means being prepared for varied financing situations and potentially longer timelines for some buyers.

Invest in High-Quality Photos & Virtual Staging
Older buyers often decide whether to see a home in person based on its online presentation, so sleek staging, high-quality photos and virtual tours can make your home stand out from the competition. A polished online listing is especially important for attracting out-of-town buyers or those who rely on digital tools to narrow their options before scheduling an in-person visit.

Emphasize the Lifestyle
Mature buyers care about the house, yes, but they’re also buying into a lifestyle. Walkability, nearby amenities, safety and local community events can all influence their decision. They also want a neighborhood where their children and grandchildren feel safe and excited to visit. Make sure your listing and marketing materials include details about what makes your neighborhood appealing, from parks and shops to quiet streets and community culture.
​

Ready to Navigate This Market?

Selling a home today isn’t like it used to be. First-time buyers are older, and repeat buyers dominate the market. But that doesn’t mean you can’t get top dollar — it just takes the right strategy. At Golden Homes Group MN, we know how to position your home and highlight the right features. If you’re ready to sell, let’s work together to make sure your listing stands out!

Sheri Wessel
Office: 651-379-5252
Mobile: 651-270-7157
Email: [email protected]    

Melaney Thelander
Office: 651-379-5252
Mobile: 651-500-8789​
Email: [email protected]   

​